back

Coalitions that last will be the ones that give up (some) power

Published
12/11/2026
Related People
Share

By Ivor Chipkin

The 2026 local government elections have done to the municipal sphere what the 2024 national election did to national government. The ANC no longer holds an outright majority in any metropolitan council, even falling below 50% in places which have been, until now, unassailable bastions: Mangaung in the Free State and, especially, Buffalo City in the Eastern Cape. Of 213 councils, 139 are hung. The future of local government now lies in the quality of coalitions.

Voters rewarded parties they believe can govern, and penalised those that have failed, primarily the ANC, but also the EFF. What matters to them is whether a coalition can improve the municipality they live in. So what causes municipal failure, how do the parties understand it, and what do they propose?

The ANC manifesto has the most developed argument, which rests on the financial framework. Municipalities receive less than 10% of the national budget, too little to fund services and infrastructure. Politicised appointments blur lines between politicians and officials, and high staff turnover makes matters worse. The ANC proposes that a larger share of national revenue goes to municipalities, and grants that reward maintenance of services and infrastructure. The EFF agrees that municipalities are underfunded, putting the share at 9%, with much of it lost to consultants, mismanagement and corruption.

The DA and ActionSA emphasise governance instead. Connected appointees, rather than professionals, run budgets and infrastructure, and corruption and instability paralyse councils. On finance, the DA blames weak collection and non-payment, rather than the funding model. ActionSA shares this analysis and adds immigration. It campaigned under the slogan “Put South Africans first”, and Herman Mashaba has said that agreement on removing undocumented migrants is a non-negotiable condition of any coalition.

It is tempting to dismiss these positions, because coalition talks are exercises in raw power and numbers. That is a mistake. Sound coalition practice no longer treats office-seeking and policy-seeking as alternatives, and local experience shows why. The Mapungubwe Institute for Strategic Reflection’s (MISTRA) study of municipal coalitions found that those excluding the party with the largest percentage of the vote tended to unravel, while those including it lasted. One reading is that coalitions built on expedience alone are the least stable. Lasting coalitions need some agreement on policy to last and to be successful.

Can such a consensus be found? I believe so, but only if coalitions focus on the real source of the problem.

Before 1994, municipalities were urban, and rural areas outside the homelands fell under the provinces. After 1994, municipalities were created across the board, so that rural areas became municipalities and towns and cities acquired large hinterlands. That model is flawed and has created municipalities without an adequate revenue base.

It does not follow that the financial framework is the main problem, however. Antony Altbeker’s study for the Centre for Development and Enterprise shows that Johannesburg’s finances are unsustainable because spending exceeds revenue, and collection has collapsed. Unpaid bills rose from R15 billion in 2014/15 to over R71 billion in 2024/25. The number of municipal employees rose from 24,620 to 34,453 and average pay from about R400,000 to R602,000 a year. This is a governance failure, not a funding one. Nationally, Michael Sachs has shown that financial allocations to local government have quadrupled as a share of GDP over thirty years, without any general improvement in municipal performance.

The evidence points to governance failure, a view consistent with how millions of South Africans voted. The problem is not primarily the ANC’s cadre deployment policy, however. Deployment happens because the law invites it. The council appoints the mayor, the municipal manager and senior officials, so the line between politicians and administrators is blurred by design. Where DA councils have done better, it is because they have used their powers in council to appoint professional as opposed to patrimonial administrations.

What does this mean for the coming negotiations? The DA and ActionSA agree that administrative roles have been politicised. The ANC’s manifesto says the same. In most councils these parties are the key players, so there is enough common ground for a minimum policy agenda. I propose four terms.

First, partners should agree that neither the council nor the coalition will select the municipal manager or chief financial officer. In metros and secondary cities, where skills are available, an independent commission established by the council should do so, with members drawn from professional bodies (like the Engineering Council of South Africa) and residents’ associations, with its proceedings open to the media. The council should then grant the municipal manager the power to appoint senior staff. In smaller and rural municipalities, where skills are scarce, councils should hand selection to the Public Service Commission, whose mandate now extends to local government under the Act signed in September, or to a recruitment agency working under it. Neighbouring municipalities under similar coalitions could share a management team.

Second, partners should commit to a funded budget as Treasury defines it, to an independent revenue forecast before it is tabled, to voting for the budget they helped prepare, and to a continuity budget if it fails.

Third, the agreement should set up a coalition management committee, a deadlock resolution procedure with deadlines and a mediator agreed to in advance.

Fourth, partners should adopt the principle in the Municipal Structures Amendment Bill that a motion to remove an office-bearer may be tabled only once in a twelve-month period, and agree not to support any no confidence motion from a non-coalition partner without first using the dispute process.

The coalitions that last will be the ones that limit their own power and allow a professional administration to emerge.

This article was published in Business Day.

Related Content